Court Overturns Louisiana’s Congressional Map

Shreveport, LA – New Congressional Map Declared Unconstitutional

A controversial map of Louisiana’s congressional district, which introduced a second predominantly Black district, has been thrown out by a federal three-judge panel. This decision, which came at the end of a three-day trial in Shreveport, has set the state’s political boundaries into a contentious phase, with the November election less than seven months away.

An Unconstitutional Move?

The ruling, emerging from a 2-1 decision, reinforced plaintiffs who insisted that the new map, brought to life by the state’s Republican-dominated Legislature and given legal backing by GOP Gov. Jeff Landry, comprised solely racial considerations and was thus unconstitutional. Judges Robert Summerhays and David Joseph from the U.S. Western District, backed the plaintiffs’ claim. The only dissenting voice was Judge Carl Stewart from the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals.

What Lies Ahead?

Following the decision, the court has planned a status conference on May 6 to discuss the remedial process. Louisiana’s chief elections officer, Jeff Landry, has emphasized the need for clarity by May 15 to allow for the November 5 election to proceed without obstacles. At the core of the dispute are the political futures of current officeholders and the issue of proportional representation for Black voters in Louisiana. This demographic constitutes about one-third of the state’s population, yet until this development, only had representation in one of the six state congressional districts.

The Disputed Map

The source of the dispute comes from a lawsuit that assailed the new majority Black 6th Congressional District, attacking its extended boundaries as unconstitutional. The district stretches across Baton Rouge, Lafayette, Alexandria, and Shreveport. Critics argue that the district does not align with traditional redistricting principles like maintaining communities of interest and compactness. Even so, the state maintained that other factors, such as protecting the political standing of republican incumbents, contributed to the design of the map.

Sacrificing the 6th District

One consequence of this protectionism was the risk it posed for Republican U.S. Rep. Graves, the current representative of the 6th District. The new map dismantled his district’s boundaries, replacing them with those of a majority Black voter population. Graves has since insisted that the map was unconstitutional and predicted it would be rejected in the federal court.

Echoes of Previous Litigations

This lawsuit is not unique but instead revives previous litigation challenging the state’s congressional boundaries. Last year, a federal appeals court signaled its intent to affirm an earlier ruling that insisted on the redrawing of Louisiana’s congressional map. This adjustment was to facilitate a second majority Black district, in respect of the Voting Rights Act.

Fighting for Equal Representation

The ruling builds on previous collective efforts by various civil rights and voting rights groups such as the NAACP Legal Defense Fund and ACLU. These organizations have been engaged in court battles for over two years, advocating for a second Black majority district. Despite today’s disappointing outcome, they remain hopeful that Louisiana will eventually establish two majority Black congressional districts.

Contact Us

For more updates about Louisiana’s Congressional districting, follow us on our social media platforms or contact us directly.